Most think BF'ing moms are stupid

Katherine - posted on 03/24/2011 ( 6 moms have responded )

65,414

232

Cafemom
If you're thinking of breastfeeding your baby, be warned: People will think you're stupid. That's right, a recently published report highlighted not one, but three studies that found people think of women who breastfeed as less competent than "otherwise identical women."

Are you shaking with fury? I'm shocked. Perhaps I shouldn't be, but I am. I knew there were plenty of people out there who get uncomfortable around women nursing (boobs, omg!); even Facebook can't handle fake boobs. BUT I still thought they were at least cool with it if done incognito. Guess not.

INCOMPETENT?!

According to Miller-McCune, in one study, participants were given two descriptions of actress Brooke Shields -- one included "bottle-feeding," and the other included "breastfeeding." Those who read she was breastfeeding found her "significantly more warm and friendly compared to the bottle-feeding mother, but significantly less competent in general, and less competent in math specifically,”

Hear that breastfeeders? You may be warm and friendly, but you suck at math. It wasn't just men either. They found men AND women held these prejudices against breastfeeding women. So much for supporting our sisters. Oh, and to add to the insult, the study found participants would be least likely to give a job to a breastfeeding woman. Not so surprised by that one, but still maddening to see it confirmed again.

What a slap in the face for all of us who try so hard to do the right thing for our babies. Breastfeeding can be hard, really hard. But those who choose to do so fight through the bleeding cracked nipples, the mastitis, and the glares of strangers because we are smart enough to know it's good for our babies. Hell, women who breastfeed are the MOST competent people I know. When I had to quit breastfeeding my children for various reasons, that's when I felt the least competent.

No wonder the rate of American women breastfeeding is "stagnant and low," according to the CDC. While it shouldn't matter what anyone else thinks, it's infuriating that they do think like this. All this discrimination against breastfeeders is beyond disturbing -- for the health of the country really.

So what are women to do? Keep breastfeeding! Jessi Smith, who led the research, told Miller-McCune:

More visible breastfeeding mothers should prompt people to wrestle with and debate the issues. With time, greater numbers of women who breastfeed translates to less prejudice.

Let's hope so.

Have you ever felt like people think you're incompetent for breastfeeding? Are you surprised that so many people hold this belief?




I am shocked so many people hold this belief. I mean based on WHAT?????
I wonder who they polled....

Join Circle of Moms

Sign up for Circle of Moms and be a part of this community! Membership is just one click away.

Join Circle of Moms

6 Comments

View replies by

Raychel - posted on 04/11/2011

149

21

I was shocked by this. I am not a breast feeding mother and I did bottle feed. However let me tell you I tried very hard to breast feed. Me and my husband planned everything out about it. We went to classes and meetings and was "trained" on how to breast feed basically (first child want to be ready). My son was born and first feeding had the nurse in there to help and he wouldnt latch on...got a shield out and on and he latched on to that like a pro. Nursed for like an hour and he was still hungry. Doctor said not a problem milk probably hasnt finished coming in, try later baby will get it. Yeah he would only nurse if I had the shield on and he woud nurse for an hour and scream afterwards. After a week of this I felt exhausted and frustrated. Doctor said to try pumping and I just wasnt making enough for my baby. I felt like a failure. I couldnt provide for my baby like I was suppose to. and than i have a friend who had her baby a month after me and she didnt even want to BF and she is like a milk cow! How fair is that??

I envy mothers who can breastfeed. I dont think it has anything to do with education. I am from a small town in TX and there are billboards with Breast is Best. Every Doctor has the posters and little info sheets on breast feeding. Our malls and stores and churchs and every other place have malls for breast feeding but you can even do it in public! I was fully prepared to do that and use those special rooms for breast feeding and I wanted to be able to feed at the park (with coverings) Now my son is 19 months and very independent but he still needs his mommy. I know dont feel like I failed him because I had to bottle feed. And he still slept in bed with us up until he was 12months and he wanted more room to sleep. And I still get those ads on half the sites I visit that say "breast is best" - "breast feeding can help prevent cancer" and I'm like yeah but if I get examed I can catch the cancer pretty early.

So it's so long I just wanted to share my story and tell each of you that I don't think you are any less of a mother because you breast feed and that even though I couldnt BF my son maybe with our next child I will be able to.

Liz - posted on 04/04/2011

1,253

22

Well, this is an American survey. It would be interesting to see more international results.

I guess formula-feeding seems high-tech or something. "You always know how much they're getting!" Sounds like a advertising slogan or something.

Mary Renee - posted on 03/30/2011

831

16

That's ok, because I secretely think bottle-feeding mothers are either ignorant or selfish...

And all studies show that breastfeeding is more common among women that have been to college and are more educated.

It's studies like this that make me breastfeed in public with out a cover, just to shove it in other people's faces. Haha Suck it! Literally.

Aleks - posted on 03/28/2011

540

0

Yeah, I agree with what Lisa said.

Animalistic behaviour definitively gets the "backward" and hence very unintelligent title.



And hey, I must have done *something* (wink wink, nudge nudge) to get my 2 degrees (finance and economics too ;-p)!!! What, being blond and having naturally huge (pam anderson sized, but she's got implants kinda huge) boobs, and still breastfeeding a... wait for it, shock horror, a two year old!!!! Not to mention a migrant from Eastern Europe and not only that, a refugee to boot!!! Now, surely cannot be anywhere near smart!!! Bah, normal intelligence wouldn't even fit that decription, could it????



May be they should sack those people who did award me those degrees... must have definitively been some inappropriate behaviours there. LOL



Ahhh... the general opinions of the GENERAL public! LMAO!

What does that tell you about the intelligence of the general population, hugh? ;-)

Minnie - posted on 03/26/2011

7,075

9

Biological function involving bodily fluids= animalistic= barbaric and unintelligent.



Me, I'm made of pixie dust, don't know about the rest of you mammals.

Ally - posted on 03/24/2011

66

7

How discouraging! I know I'm the odd one out among friends, but I had no idea society as a whole so pervasively looked down on it. Sad. I guess that's part of why I try to be as open about it as I can be, but I'm getting quieter about it as my daughter, approaching 3, gets older. She is learning from me that we don't talk about it in front of other people. I thought I was doing it out of respect for privacy, but she asked me why people don't think it's nice to talk about it. This makes me think twice about being quieter about it. Maybe people need to hear more about it instead of less! Then again, I don't know that I am ready to be the poster child... Sheesh! This is terrible!