Making formula available by prescription only...

Jodi - posted on 09/28/2010 ( 10 moms have responded )

2,694

52

I just heard about a proposal in Australia to make formula available by prescription only! I have to admit...I agree...as long as they make it feasible to GET the formula when needed. Read the link:
http://www.couriermail.com.au/lifestyle/...

I could not find her entire proposal unfortunately, but that's the basic idea. I think it would be GREAT, and not just for Australia, but for the U.S., Canada, make it global. Like I said, it needs to be feasible. We'll have to increase the amount of lactation consultants and make sure doctors are thuroughly and properly educated on breastfeeding, the road blocks and how to combat them. Mothers should have a 24/7 hotline to call WITH consultants that can get to your house at a moment's notice at 2 a.m. if need be to help with issues like, latch, positioning, supply, growth spurts etc etc etc. I also think that the consultants should be able to give out prescriptions and for the cases where a mother calls at 2 a.m. and the consultant deems formula neccessary can give the mother a 24 hour sample of formula until she can fill the prescription.
I don't think that formula should be absolutely impossible to get either, I just think that a mother should give it a try and have educated help starting and combating issues that most commonly prevent mothers from having a successful breastfeeding relationship. I always hear that it's a parent's right how to feed their child, but what about the baby's right to proper, IDEAL and natural nutrition? This would ensure that a mother CAN get formula if it "isn't for her" (as is one of the reasons I hear SOOOO often) and that baby is given the opportunity to the best and most nutritional food supply straight off the bat.
Besides that, medications are much more regulated than any food, ensuring much higher quality formula for babies/mothers who do need it. Formula companies would surely advertise less, leaving more money just for the purpose of investing it into better ingredients, better safety precautions and again, ensuring higher quality formula. Besides that, as a medication, it would be covered by most insurances, saving cost to the mother who does NEED the formula.
Mothers win in being given the proper support they need to breastfeed AND still have the option to formula feed if neccessary. Babies win with being allowed the best nutrition straight off the bat. Society would win with higher breastfeeding rates which would/could result in a smarter and healthier future population while also lowering breastcancer rates. The only ones NOT benefiting from this scenario is the multi-billion dollar formula industries.

Obviously, I support this movement with the proper guidance to ensure certain rights (such as, not forcing a mother to breastfeed and undergo undue stress and resentment simply because the has the ability to lactate). I have nothing against mothers who use formula for WHATEVER reason, my issue is with the medical society and it's lack of education and support on the subject of breastfeeding and with the money hungry formula industries who don't give two hoots about the health of our children but only making the mommies feel secure and happy while forking over millions of dollars for inferior food. What are your thoughts? And let's keep it civil please ladies! We're all grown-ups...this is controversial...but let's keep in mind, while we may have toddlers and young kids at home...we ourselves are not children and conduct ourselves appropriately! Thanks!

Join Circle of Moms

Sign up for Circle of Moms and be a part of this community! Membership is just one click away.

Join Circle of Moms

10 Comments

View replies by

Ashley - posted on 10/01/2010

29

6

I think that is a good idea however if they cannot get a prescription fast enough and the baby runs out of formula or the mother has supply issues, it could cause a problem.

Daniela - posted on 09/29/2010

638

8

Have to correct myself on the milk bank. I was just informed that the one in Northern Ireland is open to the Republic, too. Ah well, next time...

Daniela - posted on 09/29/2010

638

8

Wow, what an idea! Normally I don't really like the idea of a nanny-state, but then that's what I said before the smoking ban in Ireland came in and now I am all for it, as it makes life just so much better. It would definitely change the way people think about breastfeeding which on it's own would already make a huge difference. Breastfeeding rates in Ireland are extremely low, which makes those of us who do it feel a bit like the odd one out. Nursing a toddler is even more uncommon and perceived as a little strange. I'm sure most doctors would still happily dish out prescriptions for formula and that's just as it should be, but it wouldn't be seen as being the first choice anymore. There are plenty of reasons why a women might want to use formula, but at present it's the breastfeeding mother who has to explain her choice. But I do agree that something like this has to go hand in hand with much more education and support. Oh, and Laura: no donor milk banks in Ireland. We have a long way to go yet.

Amy - posted on 09/29/2010

5,605

33

Like someone stated in the states a mom only gets 6 to 8 weeks paid. The rest is then unpaid and can only stay out for 12 weeks protected by Family Medical leave, although my particular company allows 16 weeks because I believe California offers 16 so they just offer it company wide. As a full time working mom we have supplemented with formula. I know that if I were not in charge at my employer I would be very uncomfortable pumping. At least now I get to kick my subordinates out of the office an put up a do not disturb sign but I can't imagine having to ask someone to vacate their office every time I needed to pump. I do think some moms are misinformed about bf'ing but I don't think that we will ever have to go to a prescription here!

Laura Zoey - posted on 09/29/2010

9,269

169

I've said this for a while now, my husband is very vocal about his views on formula too! I think his friends were all offended first off by his bluntness but now they all see the truth in our mindset.
It's true, most moms give up or don't try because they think it's not a big deal. That's why I tell anyone who will listen of the risks of formula feeding. Risks up to death! So it's not a chocolate or vanilla choice, it's a spinach salad or bag of cheese puffs choice. Choose lightly and your child will have to live with the side effects. Yes some babies do require formula, galactosemic babies, but all others who need bottles deserve human milk in it!
If we had readily available donor milk banks it would help too. And moms willing to do the stupid pumping stuff to donate. Yes, I will be donating with the next baby. Even though I detest pumping. It's well worth it in the end when babies get actual human milk even when they can't get it from mom.
So until we can do this radical change,.....donate! It's the best way to help right now!

Janice - posted on 09/29/2010

1,890

18

I definitely agree that women are not supported enough in breastfeeding. I think everything proposed is great. However, like another posted this is not going to happen in America any time soon. Formula has sadly become the norm. In America you are expected back at work in 6-12 weeks. Pumping at work is not possible in many professions and therefore everything about our culture "demands" formula. I am lucky that I am home while I finish my degree so I didn't have any breastfeeding obstacles. Since I get nothing when I pump my next child might be deprived of breast milk because I will be working. This is a great proposal but in America there are soooo many obstacles.

Jodi - posted on 09/29/2010

2,694

52

I'm from the United States (don't know about you ladies) and quite frankly, I don't even see a glimmer of hope of this coming through anytime soon. It's 2010 as we just passed a federal law this year protecting a woman's right to nurse in public. A great step forward, but I think it would be years, probably decades, before something this HUGE would be anything but laughed at and brushed aside. I just think that most woman assume right off the bat that breastfeeding is too hard and not normal and so don't, OR, they do try and are miserably failed by their medical staff and their peers and their valiant attempts are unsuccessful due to something that is compeltely avoidable. THIS proposal, if put into action, would ensure a woman gets the help and support she needs, while still keeping formula a viable option.

Danielle - posted on 09/29/2010

5

6

I agree with everything you've said. The WHO themselves say formuls feeding should be the 4th option, after breastfeeding, feeding the mothers' expressed milk, or feeding another human mothers' milk. Yet so many people seem to jump straight to formula, some without even attempting to breastfeeding. But there does need to be much more support out there for Mums, I am a peer supporter for my local PCT and don't think there are enough health care professionals out there to help, us peer supporters are relyed on heavily but are not allowed to do that much when it comes to it!

Danielle - posted on 09/28/2010

53

30

I agree with you. Mothers are not informed enough to get off to the best start. And doctors dont know anything really about nursing. New mothers really need someone to tell them they can do it instead of just give a bottle. we need to support and give love to everyone involed. I EBF twins but if i didnt have my mother to help me in beginning i would have gone crazy. I have always said that formula should be a RX. Our children would be getting the very best start, and healthy. I hope when my girls nurse their babies, breastfeeding is the norm instead of formula.