Immersion Programs ...

Deborah - posted on 04/13/2009 ( 3 moms have responded )

385

7

My daughter is 2 1/2 and will turn 3 at the end of the summer. She is set to start a preschool attached to a church 3 times a week starting in the fall. The program is more socialization then academics but they do have curriculum and my daughter is leap years ahead of their curriculum but they do it in such a way that I am hoping she finds pleasure in it and isn't bored. BUT I will be on the look out for signs of it not being a proper fit and have been looking into alternative schools.

One thing that is important to us is foreign language and teaching her Spanish right now. (We chose Spanish due to our location and how it will be more readily available in after school programs.) Due to the importance of it I started looking into Immersion Programs in our area and came across a Spanish Immersion Program which we went to an open house this weekend. I was impressed with a lot of it. They are academically more advanced then the public schools in this area. Their curriculum is about 2 years ahead of the PS. All their teachers are certified in Mexico and the textbooks come from Mexico which are big check marks in my book. BUT as advanced as they are it really opened my eyes to how advanced my daughter really is. She would be in their 3 yr old program by age but she already knows all of the curriculum taught to 4 year olds and about half of the kindergarten curriculum. The challenge of this program for her would be learning the language but she quickly picks up Spanish words in her English world so in an immersion environment I fear that she will absorb it a lot faster and then in a matter of a few months she will really understand them and the curriculum will be too slow for her. I did talk to the Director and she said they could evaluate her at the beginning of the year and see if they need to move her to the next level but I really don't know if that is evaluating her Spanish ability or her understanding of the curriculum in the English context. And if they decide she needs to be in the 3 yr old class due to her Spanish and she masters comprehension before the year she would clearly be stuck in that class b/c they only have 1 class per age and their classes are full with waiting lists.

So my question is ... has anyone gone done this path with their gifted child and if so was it a good decision?

My plan is to send her to the social program but have back ups ready in case it isn't a fit. So I am also going to look into a French Immersion Montessori school b/c if it is a true Montessori it might allow her the foreign language component that we desire and be able to keep up with her pace.

Also, we did sign her up for the summer program for Spanish Immersion and hopefully that will give me some sign of how quick she is to absorb it.

Join Circle of Moms

Sign up for Circle of Moms and be a part of this community! Membership is just one click away.

Join Circle of Moms

3 Comments

View replies by

Deborah - posted on 04/14/2009

385

7

Maybe the fact that immersion involves another language she might not be bored so quickly and again ... this is her first experience in school so she might very well be content in the social environment and this is a non-issue. But just in case....

Morag - posted on 04/14/2009

304

14

Lil miss is kind of on in an immersion class so to speak, we live in Spain and English nursery schools cost too much, so she goes to a Spanish one. She'll be going to Spanish school anyway so felt it was a good heads up. I know your daughter is a bit older than my youngest, but my eldest was the same age when she started Spanish school. It took her around 3 months to fully digest the language. By which time they are slightly behind academically, but not much and my eldest only had problems catching up because she has dyslexia.

Lil miss though, who really is leap years ahead of, not only her age group, but her sister when her sister was the same age, started saying Spanish words in 2 weeks of her first day and within 6 she was speaking lots of phrases and understood it completely. Now we speak no Spanish at home, neither does her other carers (the grandmas only speak Swedish and English), we don't watch a lot of TV and even then not much in Spanish. Lil miss only goes to nursery half days (Mon, Wed, Fri - 9:30 til 1:30 and Tue,Thurs - 3.30 to 6:30), so her knowledge of Spanish has been impressive considering the time frame. Your LO will probably be the same, especially if you start her in a summer program.

I assume the Spanish school is technically a private school, which means you should be more able to discuss your options as to moving her up the grades, rather than keeping her in a lower grade :) Lil miss' nursery school is private and we have been able to discuss moving her up into the older age group where they teach them counting and colours, which was no problem. We've also been very lucky because the teacher just loves teaching lil miss because she loves learning, and learns so fast.

The only thing I will say is that Spanish has become her preferred language over English, despite her being mostly in an English speaking environment. We have come to the conclusion that this is because she must see Spanish as the language that lil miss sized people speak and therefore the language she thinks she should converse in. Plus everyone but my mum understands Spanish so its not like she's not understood most of the time so probably doesn't even realise that not everyone understands. You might not have that problem, but its something to be aware of.

Rebekah - posted on 04/13/2009

163

12

Deborah,

Henry goes to a Spanish enrichment at his Montessori 2x a week. We are doing the Spanish immersion in the fall. Of course, the immersion will be a different environment because it will be a regular classroom rather than the small, guided language class he has now. I can't say for sure how that will go, and I expect they'll still need to find ways to challenge him in that setting, but with what he has been doing so far with language, he doesn't seem to mind going over colors, numbers, letters, days of the week, etc in Spanish and really enjoys having languages as a kind of game for himself. He used to be in the habit of giving a "funny" incorrect answer when people asked him things that he thought were too easy and now he just answers in Spanish or French. It still throws the adults for a loop because they're expecting English, but at least he's not intentionally giving the wrong answer to prove a point.