Kids raised by same sex marriage are better off

Katherine - posted on 07/25/2011 ( 4 moms have responded )




The Stir

Everybody knows that kids brought up in a "normal" two-parent household -- "normal" meaning that the two parents are a heterosexual married couple, of course -- turn out just the way they're supposed to, right? It's as easy as baking cookies: Follow the recipe exactly and presto! You'll be rewarded with perfect cookies.

What's that you say? The formula doesn't always work so well? You'd think it was foolproof, given the "outrage" over NYC couples like Andy Berg and Dominic Pisciotta, who are now raising their children as a legally married pair. Not that they were raising them any differently before, or that they weren't doing such a fabulous job that it was the kids who insisted their dads be married on the very first day it was possible for same-sex couples to get married by the state. The point is, now that it's "official," people feel the need to drag out the old dead "children need a mother and a father" horse and beat it up some more. Really?

You might find this shocking, but guess what? Growing up with a "mom" and "dad" doesn't stop kids from having issues, nor does growing up with a mom and a mom or a dad and a dad or just a mom or just a dad guarantee that kids will have issues. I know this for a fact.

My parents weren't together when I was a kid -- I barely even saw my dad until I was about 18 (though we developed a very strong relationship after that, which I never expected to happen). Now it's my turn to play divorced mom -- but it's a different gig than the one my mom had, because, unlike me, my two kids get to see their dad all the time.

So, here's something I've noticed, as a lifelong resident of "broken homes." Actually, another product (and creator) of a broken home said it best, years ago, so you'll excuse me if I borrow his words to tell you the secret to raising a happy, healthy family:

All you need is love.

Kids need to be raised by people who love them, first and foremost. This is a million times more important than any other quality in a parent, eclipsing gender, finances, religion ... everything. Kids need to feel loved and they need to know that the people they love also love each other. It's when bitterness, anger, and resentment take the place of love in a family that kids come out either burnt or half baked.

I'm pretty sure Andy Berg and Dominic Pisciotta's kids are going to be some of the best cookies ever.

Do you think the most important ingredient in raising a family is love?

Interesting to say the least.


Amber - posted on 07/25/2011




Love is definitely important. But so are stability, time, respect, patience, and an ability to work through problems.

I don't think you can look at a single factor and say, "Yep, there it is. That's the magic ingredient."

I'll keep with their analogy of baking. If love is missing and the cookies end up burned, then the timer must have been missing.

But maybe stability is the flour and time spent with your children is the eggs....those are going to be some disgusting cookies in the end if you don't have those ingredients.

No recipe is complete without ALL of the proper ingredients.

If you see this, leave this form field blank.
Powered by RESPECT not THUMPS


View replies by

Stifler's - posted on 07/26/2011




here's one thing i've noticed... everyone ends up having issues. no one's life is perfect and i don't believe it's anything to do with the sexuality of your parents!

Katherine - posted on 07/26/2011




I agree with you Joanna, about the tolerance part. What I don't agree with is that "love" is going to make it all better. You definitely need more than that and I love Amber analogy.

Firebird - posted on 07/26/2011




You know, I once miscalculated and put a cup less flour than needed into a batch of cookies and they were spoiled. Runny and burnt. Not very nice. Like Amber says, there is no magic ingredient, there are many different, equally necessary aspects of home life that make the best kids. Those can be found in any kind of home, doesn't matter how many parents there are or what their genders are. It takes all sorts. One thing I feel comfortable saying is that kids raised by same sex parents are likely to be brought up in a more tolerant home than a lot of other people.

Join Circle of Moms

Sign up for Circle of Moms and be a part of this community! Membership is just one click away.

Join Circle of Moms