More Couples Sleeping Apart: Is This Healthy?

Meghan - posted on 08/02/2010 ( 24 moms have responded )

1,957

44

A recent article in The New York Times points out the trend of more and more couples sleeping in separate rooms. Nearly one in four American couples does so and, according the National Association of Home Builders, it's expected that 60 percent of custom homes will have dual master bedrooms by 2015.

This got us thinking: Is this a healthy trend? I mean, sure, occasionally we think we'd get a better night's sleep with a wall (or two) between us and our snoring, TV-watching, sheet-hogging Sig O. But would our relationship suffer?

To get to the bottom of it, we asked Tina B. Tessina, Ph.D. (a.k.a. Dr. Romance), psychotherapist and author of Money, Sex, and Kids: Stops Fighting About the Three Things That Can Ruin Your Marriage, for her take:

"Sleeping apart can contribute to the disconnect that plagues many relationships," Tessina says. "It just makes it easier to avoid each other, when what's really needed is connection and contact. There are solutions to snoring and restlessness -- a memory foam mattress will stop restlessness from being felt by a partner and snoring can be helped in a number of ways."

A bit more motivation to sleep in the same bed:

* Your man may get a better night's sleep when you're with him. In a study published in the journal Sleep and Biological Rhythms, researchers found that while women slept less soundly when they shared a bed with someone they're romantically involved with, men actually slept better when next to a woman. Work out whatever issues you have with his sleeping habits and you both might get some high-quality shut-eye.

* Bedtime isn't always for sleep, if you catch our drift. It's also prime for intimacy: snuggling and sex. This private time is crucial, especially if you have kiddies (a.k.a. nookie police). Sure you could meet him in "his" room, get it on, then flee back to "your" room. But then sex becomes a scheduled chore rather than an organic, meaningful, spontaneous activity.

* Nighttime, while you're side by side, is one of the best times to communicate with each other. Between work and other responsibilities, you only have small snippets of uninterrupted time to communicate during the day. With the door shut (and iPhones snuggled into their charging stations), between the sheets is the place where you can truly talk about what's on your mind, without interruption by kid, dog, phone, cable guy, etc. "Cuddling up together and talking quietly is a great perk of married life," says Tessina. "Couples who know how to do that, and do it regularly, fare better than couples who don't."
Bottom line: Try to solve whatever sleep incompatibility issues exist between you and your partner before fleeing for the guest room.

Does your significant other have any sleeping habits that drive you nutty? Would you consider sleeping in a separate bedroom?

This conversation has been closed to further comments

Join Circle of Moms

Sign up for Circle of Moms and be a part of this community! Membership is just one click away.

Join Circle of Moms

24 Comments

View replies by

Karen - posted on 10/03/2011

321

9

We resorted to seperate bedrooms in order to get enough sleep to survive. We found that constant sleep deprivation for both of us was a lot more harmful to our family than sleeping in different rooms.

Kitty - posted on 10/03/2011

625

17

yes i agree with alot of this but mine snores he is on a breathing mask now and he is haveing issues with it i would love one night were he puts it on all night and doesnt take it off and i can sleep all night with out knowing he is there!.. would be awesome!!!! im alight sleeper soo this is very hard!!!!

Cyndel - posted on 08/08/2010

752

24

I can't sleep if my hubby isn't beside me. He goes to school an hour away and sometime has to stay over night at my parents house (who live in the same city as the school) because of studying for a test (we can only get satelite internet because of our location but cannot afford it) or gas money issues (btw, my hubby has adopted my parents as his own so staying with the in-laws is no issue) about once a week some times every two weeks. I end up staying up until the early hours and then sleeping restlessly for a few hours before baby wakes me up at 6:30-7:00am. So separate beds is not an option for us. Nor do I believe it is healthy for the marriage if the couple sleeps in separate rooms. it gives an excuse for not discussing issues the couple is having difficulty with.

Lyndsay - posted on 08/07/2010

2,008

19

Most days my hubby sleeps on the couch, now that its summer. We only have an air conditioner in the living room and he gets so overheated the fans just don't cut it for him. I, on the other hand, am warm blooded and absolutely detest cold air blowing on me. So.. right now, he's sleeping on the couch.

On the bright side, we usually go to bed together. We will lay there for awhile and talk, sometimes have sex (not often, usually I just want to pass out), and then I will settle into a sleep and he will just get frustrated that he's sweating and go out to the air conditioner. Then I get the whole bed to myself. :)

Isobel - posted on 08/06/2010

9,849

0

my "hubby" snores like the nasty hairy beast that he is...then he steals my blankets and yells at me for being a blanket hog while I lay their without any...



I think separate rooms might be better ;)

Jenny - posted on 08/06/2010

4,426

16

Some couples need seperate sleeping areas to survive. If I didn't have an escape from my partner's snoring I would smother him. It's not every night but some nights I must escape for the safety of my family.

Meghan - posted on 08/06/2010

3,169

33

LOL, I've been joking lately that if I do get into another serious relationship this is how I am going to do things!
If both people are on the same page and no one gets offended by it why the heck not?

Sally - posted on 08/06/2010

858

14

In a majority of the world, for a majority of history, with whom you sleep is defined by gender instead of martital status. We are the oddballs in that realm. Many of the cultures where husbands and wives are expected to sleep saparately seem to have many more children than we do so I have trouble believing their sex lives are that much worse than ours.

Louise - posted on 08/06/2010

5,429

69

Well ladies I can see both sides of this one. My husband and I have slept apart for the last 6 years becuase my husband has night terrors, sleepwalks and snores. This nearly tore us apart last year but we are on the mend. I start the night off in our bedroom and then move every night at some point into the back room. In fact I prefer to sleep alone. I get up first every morning for a cuddle before the alarm clock goes off. Just be careful ladies if you decide to do this make sure it is a mutual decision as the other partner will feel pushed out otherwise. We have been together for 24 years and have spent 6 years apart. It is the best sleep I have ever had!

K. - posted on 08/04/2010

187

18

I couldn't imagine sleeping in room away from my husband, He's in the Navy so he's gone enough as it is. I did however go on strike for two nights. I slept on the couch. We had a double bed! A double! Ummm, that's a bit too small. So just this past Saturday we went to the store and bought a king. Our sleep is so much better now!

Sunny - posted on 08/03/2010

662

21

We do sleep in separate rooms. I am a chronic insomniac. I stay in our bed until my partner is asleep than i move to the spare room so i can have music playing or read. I dont fall asleep until abound 4am and that is when my partner has to get up for work. We still cuddle up, talk, have sex in our bed but once he falls to sleep i have to get up. It just works better for us that way.

Toni - posted on 08/03/2010

3,671

14

Oh I forgot to say I am THE blanket hog - Erin I'm with your hubby if it is too hot to be under it cuddle it with your leg over it that rules! I am also THE bed hog - I spread out and kick my hubby til he moves out of my way :-D

But HE has tried to smother me with my pillow (ok so he didn't do it on purpose but he still whipped my pillow from under my head and put it back down on top of it) and one night when for some reason I was sleeping with my arm raised directly above my head he hit it down and woke me up...on second thoughts maybe we SHOULD get separate beds gqtm

Toni - posted on 08/03/2010

3,671

14

I miss my hubby so much when he is not with me in bed, that is the one thing I really missed when I was in hospital (17 days at the end of my pg) - sleeping with my hubby - one day the midwives told me that I would probably be sent home that night it didn't happen I spent the whole night and the next day snivelling because I just want to sleep and I meant sleep with my hubby *pouts* I want to go home - bloody pregnancy hormones!



I can't see how it can work successfully in a happy relationship - surely if couples are sleeping separately permanently than they have issues.

Amy - posted on 08/03/2010

1,761

18

Both of us a pretty good sleepers, however if I'm pregnant (and stuffy) I'll snore some. We both also have our nights where we kick and push each other off the bed (one reason we will NEVER allow our kids to sleep in the bed with us). Also, if we have a cold or something sometimes it makes it harder for the other to sleep.

Honestly, with all that aside, it takes me much longer to fall asleep when he's not in bed with me. And when the morning comes it's nicer to just nudge the other one to get up with our toddler (depending on who's day it is to sleep in).

I would never even think of having separate beds as my husband.

Erin - posted on 08/02/2010

1,535

76

My husband and I sleep in seperate blankets. We are both blanket hogs and one of us freezes all night otherwise! Plus in the summer I can't sleep with more then a sheet and that crazy man still wants him comforter to put between his legs, um...NO THANKS! I put mine away then! I don't even want it in my space to possibly touch me when its hot out!!! We have a king size bed so we don't really touch each other, except the occasional kick of feet... Currently there is a little monster in between us, thank god for the king size bed!, so not much goes on at night, but I wouldn't want seperate rooms for nothing! Well maybe a seperate room for all my crafting stuff so I could hideout for a few hours...but I'd want to do that while everyone is awake and driving me crazy :) Not when the house is soo peaceful and they are all sleeping ;) Babies aren't the only ones that are cute when they sleep ;)

Charlie - posted on 08/02/2010

11,203

111

Helena bohnam carter and her husband Tim burton live in separate houses next door to each other ........just saying .


I dont know i guess it could work for some but i prefer intimacy .

Nikki - posted on 08/02/2010

1,524

23

I think that is the recipe for disaster. I couldnt ever imagine sleeping in a different room, let alone a different bed. I love falling asleep curled up beside him, we talk about our day, we cuddle, kiss, get intimate, I cant fall asleep unless im right beside him.

Holly - posted on 08/02/2010

4,555

13

I can't imagine not sleeping in the same bed as my hubby, much less a different room! We share our bed, but we do each have our own quilt so we aren't constantly fighting over one :)

Mae - posted on 08/02/2010

190

19

My husband and I do not feel that sleeping in separate bedrooms is a great idea. my husband is very restless and I am too at times but that is part being married. It's about compromise. I love cuddle time with my husband and soo many times going to bed we get started talking and there is so much that I have learned from these talks about my husband. I can't sleep very well without my husband there. I guess I was raised sheltered but I just always assumed sleeping with someone was one of the perks of being married and never thought there were people who didn't share a bed with their significant others save those who travel. Something else I learned was that there are couples that have entirely separate bank accounts (I know I'm nieve). I just feel that it is setting youself up to separate.

Oh and the sex part of sleeping together is AWESOME! I don't think I could give that up either.

Rosie - posted on 08/02/2010

8,657

30

i don't sleep with my husband. he works the night shift. at first i was horrified at the thought of sleeping alone, i mean i NEEDED him there!! now after 2 1/2 years of it, i miss my husband, i miss the intimacy, we dont' have a chance to cuddle, kiss, let alone have sex.

and to top it all off, he has come into bed on his nights off sometimes, and it's been so long that i don't even like him there anymore! he snores, he steals the blankets, i can't sprawl all over like i'm used to, and it pisses me off i can't have it both ways!!

definitely don't recommend it to anybody if they don't have to do it.

Amber - posted on 08/02/2010

1,909

13

I occasionally grab my pillow and head to the guest bedroom when I can't fall asleep at night. Especially when I was pregnant; he would wake up in the middle of the night and have to come and find me. But I would never consider having seperate bedrooms.
We are so busy, that sometimes that's the only time that we have together. I HATE to cuddle while I'm sleeping, but we've compromised on wrapping our feet up together. And I really enjoy cuddling for a half hour to hour before we actually fall asleep. It's nice to have those calm moments in the middle of a crazy week. Even if it means having my blankets stolen or occasionally waking up being crushed :)
I do know a couple that have seperate bedrooms...and they aren't really married anymore. For some people it might work...but the times that I've seen it, it has just driven them farther apart than they previously were.

Joanna - posted on 08/02/2010

2,096

19

My husband and I are at the point where when it's nighttime, the only thing that happens in our bed is sleeping. Well, he sleeps, I don't. I would love another room/bed! He snores so loudly, plus he likes the windows open all the time, even if it's noisy outside, and I can't stand the extra sound. When I first moved in with him, his roomate moved out so I put my bed in the extra room. Some days I'd have to work at 6 am so about twice a week I'd sleep alone in the other room, and I got SO much more sleep, it was awesome!

Jennifer - posted on 08/02/2010

3,053

42

The concept of sleeping in separate beds is just an alien concept to me! When we went on holiday to Crete last September I was 28-30 weeks pregnant and in the room there were two single beds so the first thing we did was pushed them together so we could snuggle up!

I think ultimately sleeping separately would affect people in different ways. We are a very physical couple and sex is important in our marriage so it definately wouldn't work for us. I snore very loudly but my husband wouldn't change our sleeping arrangements, plus I've bought a nose clip which stops me snoring. My husband sometimes steals the blanket but I just steal it back or use an extra duvet.

As for other people, couples where one person works away a lot the other will be used to sleeping alone but I doubt they'd sacrifice sleeping in the same bed for the little amount of time they'd get for sleeping in separate beds, simply to get a better nights sleep.

Krista - posted on 08/02/2010

12,562

16

My DH is great...I'M the one who snores. And there have been times when, in the middle of the night, one of us has gone into the spare bedroom because of it. But to just give up altogether and establish separate bedrooms? No. I'd hate that. One of my favourite things in the whole world is when we're lying in bed together, just talking foolish talk about nothing in particular, and we're cracking each other up laughing. If we had separate bedrooms, I'd miss that, because you can't plan those kinds of conversations -- they just happen.