Your room: free for all, or off limits? **EDIT ADDED**

Alicia - posted on 05/31/2010 ( 210 moms have responded )

44

8

I work 5 hours a day at a high-stress job, then come home to a high-stress household. I have 6 kids. I invest alot of time cleaning, diapering, bathing, feeding, rocking, breastfeeding, encouraging, driving the carpool, going to soccer-football-track-baseball practice, and giving goodnight kisses.

I love my jobs, both of them. I love taking care of my kids.

We live in a 7 bedroom house. All of my kids have their own bedrooms. They have an oversized den, a pool, a huge yard, and a gameroom, not to mention the living room, and the kitchen they have full access to.

My room is often reffered to by me as my "oasis".

A place I can go, lock the door, and close all the noise, disruptions and problems out.

(Let the record show my kids are not the dispruptions) haha

So, I tell my kids they have the entire house, but the only thing that is off limits to them is my bedroom. They are only allowed to go in there if they have permission, or if I am in there with the door open.



How exclusive do you try to make your bedroom?



PLEASE note, that I do NOT spend all my time locked away in my bedroom at home. I dont lock my door while I am sleeping, and I dont lock it all the time during the day. My kids just grew up not going in my room, because I've raised them that way. My kids are not toddlers anymore. Well, one of them is, but I feel like I can rely a bit on my older kids (17 & 14) to help with the younger ones, (9, 5, 2) I take care of my kids.



I do not neglect my children. I spend alot of time with them. We have movie night once a week, and I go to each and every one of their sports games. I do not leave them alone all the time.



I do not consider my kids a "Job." No, i love my kids. They are my world, and I lost two kids 2 years ago, and trust me, it was not like losing a job. It was like losing part of my world.



I don't lock out morning kisses and giggles. I am overjoyed when all 6 of my kids pile in for morning kisses. They all come in in the morning, and kiss me goodbye before they get picked up by the carpool. I then get up, get my 2 year old and my baby up, and get them ready to go to the sitters. I do not lock out nightmare scared children, although my kids rarely ever have nightmares, I have been awakened by a few of them at night scared, and I do hug and hold them, but they don't sleep with us. They eventually return to their beds.



Since I've raised my kids to not go in my room, my two year old son often requests to sleep in his bed, and doesnt like to co-sleep.



I've heard "You pay the mortgage, you get the room" as well as "You're selfish" all the way to "We go in their room without asking, why should they have to ask to go in ours?"

The answer to the first one is, Yes, I do pay the mortgage, I think I do deserve to have my room to myself, which leads me to the next question, I don't go in their room without asking. My 17 year old has his own room. The only time I go in there is to wake him up in the morning. He does his laundry, he cleans his room, he makes his bed. He's not 5 anymore. my 14 year old son shares a room with my 5 year old son. He actually volunteered to do that, and my 14 year old helps my 5 y/o with cleaning and bed-making and such. My 9 y/o has her own room, and cleans her own room, and takes care of her things. My 2 y/o and my newborn currently share, and yes, I do go in their room. I clean their room, and I dont feel as though I need to ask my two year old permission to go in his room. He loves it when I'm in his room anyways. But I'm not going to ask him permission, no. He doesnt even know how to spell his own name yet... And no, I'm not selfish. My kids get alot of time with me, and I do alot for them. Having my husband and I our own room is the equivelent to us going on date night once a week. We dont typically get a date night, so we have our own room. Theres nothing in my room for my kids, so they dont need to be in there.



Alot of lovely ladies were trying to tear and thrash away at my parenting style, saying we were not a close family if we have our room to ourselves. Thats my parenting style, and we are a VERY close family. Also, to the mom who said I didn't like kids, I love kids, and if I didn't, I wouldn't have six of them :)



Feel free to leave more comments, most of them are extremely helpful, this was just to those lovely mommas who were being a little...well... not nice. :)



Thanks!!

This conversation has been closed to further comments

Join Circle of Moms

Sign up for Circle of Moms and be a part of this community! Membership is just one click away.

Join Circle of Moms

210 Comments

View replies by

Vicky - posted on 06/07/2010

4

27

Haha, we apparently have a free for all room :-)
But I love having the girls with me early in the morning. And I have early on taugth them that if they have a bad dream or feel lonely at night, they can always come to me. At least that way I didn't have to get out of bed lol

Jessica - posted on 06/06/2010

2

19

When we built our bedroom, we made sure it was big enough to have a 'lounge area' for our children to sit in and chat to us. But in saying that - when they are old enough - the 'free for all goes' and they have to knock before entering. We always allow them to come in, but they have to wait until we say so - gives us time to hide evidence (this is where all present wrapping goes on, and where we sneak the goodies for midnight snacks!) or if we've been, ahem, 'busy', - get dressed!

Sylvia - posted on 06/06/2010

1,315

8

LOL, our bedroom is not exclusive at all! TBH, the idea of making kids ask permission to go in there would never have occurred to me for one second. DD snuggles in with us most mornings, takes her baths in our bathroom (hers has only a teensy shower stall), keeps a bunch of her books and comics in there so she can lie on our bed and read, uses our bed to practice her gymnastics and martial arts (all invented -- she's never taken classes in either one), empties her little laundry hamper into the big one and gets her clean clothes from the basket to put away in her room. We sit on the floor in there to play cards and board games. Until quite recently, we read her bedtime stories in there and moved her into her own bed after she fell asleep.

Now, if DH and I are in there with the door closed, she knows she's supposed to knock. (Usually, though, she's already asleep in her own room when we close the door...) And if one of us needs some down time or is taking a nap, we close the door and she knows to leave us alone, or at least be quiet if she comes in. But we're not, frankly, that private a family -- when we have someone staying at our house, we have to remind DD to close the bathroom door when she's in there using the toilet, because we rarely do that normally. We also don't particularly care about family members seeing one another naked (although I predict that will change, on DD's part at least, as she gets older!).

Of course, we have just the one kid and live in an 800-square foot 2-bedroom flat, so ... yeah.

Jaclyn - posted on 06/06/2010

66

6

Well Alicia,
My parents room was off limits when we were younger unless we were invited in and i have a 3 1/2 yr old boy and a 18mth old boy and mummy and daddy's room is off limits unless invited in. We like to make our rooom exclusive because we also need our privacy and our time together. Though they do try and make a break for it at times and rumage through our draws but they know its off limits.

Meg - posted on 06/06/2010

38

55

YES definitely agree!!! Your room is your santuary, your own place... I have 2 step sons that know to knock before entering, and even if the door is open to ask before just walking in. My partner and i don't particualrly like them coming in, as thats our room. They are also not allowed on or in the bed, only in emergency situations....
But we also have the same rule with the boys.
Their rooms are theirs, so we also show respect and knock before entering if the door is closed etc. I guess we like to practice what we preach.
We all need our own place we can go and it's just ours! That place to get away from everything...

Sonia - posted on 06/06/2010

1

0

I have 3 kids and can imagine that you need your time!!! We usually keep our door open, but if the door is closed the kids know to knock first. We set that rule up fairly early. They are not allowed to just walk right in if it is closed unless there is some dire emergency....bleeding, throw-up, etc.....

Debra - posted on 06/06/2010

1

21

i think it should be shared for family prayers, dealing with personal conversations with individuals in the family but if the door is shut then it is not a place for kids to hang out or use my things with out asking. It is a respect issue for me. I want my kids to know they can come and be with me if needed but i want my privacy just as they want theirs.

Lyndsay - posted on 06/06/2010

2,008

19

My son is almost 3 and he's allowed in my bedroom only when I'm in there. Usually thats just when I'm getting ready to go out or putting laundry away, stuff like that.

Rachael - posted on 06/06/2010

1,673

38

my son is rarely allowed in my room. ocassionally i will bring him in here cuz he likes it cuz he isn't allowed, but not very often

Jess - posted on 06/06/2010

8

38

We brought our child into the world and our house is his house, if, when he's older, he, and any other children we may have, want to come into our room then they're more than welcome to. We go into his room without his permission.
My parents had no problems with me and my brother being in their room. No issues with having time to themselves either. Once my son goes to bed it's our time and we will eat and watch tv and have a bath.
Neither me or my husband seem to be bothered about this issue. We want a huge family and we want a noisy home where our kids are free to go where they like. We have nothing to hide.

Martina - posted on 06/06/2010

3

0

I wish I could have a big house. Unfortunately my kids, 9 and 5 have to pass through our bedroom to go to their bedroom. What an awkward arrangment! But I would definately love my privacy.

Jessie - posted on 06/06/2010

333

36

Shirley, thank you for sharing... sometimes when your in that time with the small children, or older children you forget how fleeting all these moments are. Those sound like beautiful memories. As for my husband and my room I plan on it being off limits when I decide but other than that it can be a free for all. My little girl is only 6 months and I feed her in the morning around 6 or 7 in our room and when she wakes up and we have our morning time and she usually takes an 1 hour nap there. I sometimes get to nap with her, but when she wakes up I am there and we giggle, wiggle and laugh together. So I think it's great to have your own space and maybe when I have anothr and they get older there will be only certain times they are allowed.

Shirley - posted on 06/06/2010

2

0

My daughter has 6 kids. They do not have a room of their own, nor do they have a huge house or yard to play in. BUT her room is still HER room and off limits to kids unless told to come in. Even Moms need their own private space too. But remember Mom's so do the kids. When my 2 oldest daughters were teens and had friends over to spend the night ( we had the smallest house of all their friends but our house was picked every time) the kids would get up at 2 or 3 ( if they were ever in bed) and get the carton of ice cream, some spoons, come pile up on MY BED and we would all eat ice cream. What wonderful memories they made for me. I am a senior now with grandkids and greats too. I have lost my oldest and first born to cancer a few years ago, so Moms, please don't forget to let your kids make memories for you too. One day that is all you will have.

M. Catherine - posted on 06/06/2010

1

10

Even to this day, and our youngest is 21 ! , our bedroom is still off limits - the door is usually open , but they still pause at the doorway and talk until invited in .... also all my things in the room are off-limits . We do have to remember to give children the same respect - that they have their "own" things they might not even have to share with a sibling , and their "own" oasis times especially with 5 siblings ....

Mandy - posted on 06/06/2010

233

16

I sleep with the bedroom door open, so that's kind of an open invitation to come in, but the oldest always askes 1st if she wants to come in for cuddles, and we'll get the baby from his cot and we'll all have cuddles together in the morning, but everyone sleeps in their own bed at night, and for grown-up time we shut the door and our daughter knows already at 5 that if the door is shut she must knock and wait for an answer.
My oasis is the bathroom - I run a bubble bath and disappear for an hour with a book.

Kelly - posted on 06/06/2010

1

32

I would love for my room to be off limits but my two boys, 9 and 6, think that they can come in and out as they please and it really bugs me!! They have the run of the house and my room should be a place I can go to escape. They will leave when asked to but yesterday, I was in my room getting dressed and my eldest came in and said, please don't take your bra off! Well, excuse me, it's my bedroom!! I would love for my bedroom to be completely off limits so I envy those who have managed it!

Magna - posted on 06/06/2010

8

24

When we moved into this house the first room we renovated was our room. I wanted a 'toy free' area that I could feel like 'me' in and not 'mom'. When you're married it's important to have a space you can be romantic and not reminded of the 1000's of ways you're depended on. Our kids are welcome in our room to cuddle and read stories, but they know it's 'toy free' and they sleep in their own beds. Occasionally one of them 'sneaks' in and sleeps next to my husband cuz he doesn't wake up, but normally it's kid free during the night.

Claire - posted on 06/06/2010

3

7

OMG I loved the idea of my own oasis, then I realised the person who would be utilising this luxury the most would be my husband. Then that would just leave me to struggle with the kids alone haha ;-)

Fiona - posted on 06/06/2010

1

0

free for all, my children are my life so i don't feel the need to shut them out.

Beth - posted on 06/05/2010

2

16

I commend you for your good sense. Everyone MUST have one private space. For you it is your "oasis" and your family must respect that. If you take care of you; you can take care of them better.

Nicola - posted on 06/04/2010

71

25

If the door is closed, they generally understand that it's a no-no except in emergencies. But mostly the door is open, and it's a free-for-all situation. In fact, last Saturday, I remarked to my husband that, in a 5-bedroom house, with a big living room, and a garden, how come all 3 of our kids were squashed in our bed? Both of us were up, but the kids were chilling post-breakfast with iPods and the like. It does make me smile...



The only one who regularly comes in when the door is closed is my 4-yo daughter, who likes to sneak in and wake me up on a weekend. Remember when lie-ins were 9,10 o'clock? I don't get past 8am these days!

Candice - posted on 06/04/2010

1,721

18

"My parents' bedroom was also off limits when I was growing up (unless I had a nightmare and my mom invited me to sleep on the floor next to her side of the bed)."

haha Joanna! My mom did that too!

Carolyn - posted on 06/03/2010

21

20

I guess ours is open the majority of the time. Especially if their (2 girls) bathroom is occupied, then they have to be able to get in and use ours. They don't hesitate to come ask a question or anything and we often invite them to watch something on our tv since it's the big one of the house and it's more fun. :) I rarely have "me" time though, except my naps. If I needed to lock them out though, I'd just say that I need time alone and they'd deal with it since they are 14 and 10.

Shannon - posted on 06/03/2010

1

46

It depends on who you ask, either myself or my husband. If it is up to me then my room is open to my children, all 4 of them at any time. If I really need the privacy I will tell them to wait out in the hall for a minute or two. My husband feels that it should be off limits, all the time, no questions asked.

Nikki - posted on 06/03/2010

37

29

It is the same way at my house. The kids can only come in my room if they are invited.

Debby - posted on 06/03/2010

6

3

When our kids were little there was a no sleeping with mommie or daddie rule. It was hard at first and we had to sit with them for a little while till they fell asleep but after a while they were okay with it and it turned into a good experience. They still remember when were did that with each of them and laugh about it now.

Susie - posted on 06/03/2010

32

7

The mere fact that you have 6 kids indicates to me that you have spent time in your oasis and know what you are doing. Sorry, I couldn't help myself. Seriously, I believe that it isn't the oasis vs free for all, but rather nurturing the nurturer that we always seem to be at odds with. In order to be your best at all your jobs, you very definitely need time in an oasis. The kids & hubby and pets may not understand, but in order for you to refresh your soul and find your spiritual connectedness with God, you very definitely need your God time somewhere. How wonderful it can be in the same place that your children were conceived in.

Tisha - posted on 06/02/2010

377

16

I think you are on the right track!! My husband and I have always allowed our room to be open to the kids for anything and now it is just out of control! They both have TV's in their rooms but they prefer to watch TV in our room. They have their own bathroom but prefer to use ours. So, we have now made a rule that they are not allowed in our room unless they have asked permission or are invited in. It's difficult to break this habit and I wish I had never allowed it!!!

Tanya - posted on 06/02/2010

162

9

right now my room is just another room of the house. My son is allowed in there but he is very alone. Our main floor is upstairs, and hte bedrooms, laundry is downstairs. When he is down so am I. As he gets older he will be taught that if the door is open he is allowed in, if the door is closed to knock and wait.
Right now he is too young to really leave alone for long periods of time and when he is asleep that is when I get to have my alone time

Mary - posted on 06/02/2010

23

10

I am in a two bedroom apartment with one child. My bedroom is OFF LIMITS. But it's more for safety reasons. I currently don't have plans to heavily baby-proof my room, so it's not safe for her in there anyway.

You must have a beautiful house! :D

Teresa - posted on 06/02/2010

10,689

29

Having your own space is wonderful! When I was married our room was 'mostly' off limits to our twins, but when my ex bailed on us we had to move into a tiny, 2 bedroom place. My room is not off limits cuz it's my son's room too now.

Kimberly - posted on 06/02/2010

1

12

OFF LIMITS! I learned that the hard way. Mom and DAD need their own space to go and chill out. If they are allowed in, then there is no place for you to go to count to ten.

Erin - posted on 06/02/2010

1,535

76

We have a free for ALL, I emphasize all here because my husband even lets his friends in our room :( I wish it was just free for family!!! I do not like having friends in my bedroom :( Its not often or every time they come over but they'll go back there and treat it like a garage...THATS MY ROOM! Sooo annoying! I think that there shouldn't be any real place that is "off limits" to someone who lives in the house. When my parent's room was "off limits" all that meant was we'd break in to their room and go through all their stuff! So if you have access and you know whats in there, because I allowed it, then you won't be practicing B&E and I won't feel lied to or decieved. At least that's my thought? We do occassionally go in and lock the door to have sex when we would of course NOT allow children in the room ;)

Hilda - posted on 06/01/2010

8

1

You are paying the mortgage. Don't feel guilty. You are lucky. My oasis is the the masterbedroom bathroom and husband and kids still knock on the door when I've been in there too long. I say, I'm fine and I am using the rest room. I get to read, take long showers, do my nails, toes. If you have a whole bedroom LOCK THAT DOOR AND ENJOY!

Sapphire - posted on 06/01/2010

3,206

12

My room is open to my son whenever he needs to come in. But I only have 1 child-he's 5- and we don't mind him at all in our room. We have a TV in our room, he does not. So while getting ready for work/school he likes to watch TV and snuggle in our bed. To us, it's really not a big deal at all. He also sneaks into our bed every single night. Half the time we hear him, half the time we don't and wake up with a kid in between us. We all need a good night's sleep and I don't pick any battles with sleep. I don't care whose bed you sleep in, just go to sleep! Trust me, there will be a time when my son wants the privacy away from us! But for know, we have all doors open.

Iridescent - posted on 06/01/2010

4,519

272

Same here, except our house is WAY too small. We have 5 kids and the oldest have their own rooms, the youngest 3 share. That arrangement will be changing shortly as we want to move the youngest boy in with the boys, but we also want to ensure the child he'll be sharing with has a private area for his things only when that change occurs.

Everyone needs a place to go to be left alone. The only time my children are allowed in my room is when I specifically invite them in.

Cathie - posted on 06/01/2010

46

12

Our room has always been a free for all. I love cuddles in bed with the kids in the morning. Now they are getting a bit older they have learned that if the door is closed (and locked!) they can't come in. So I guess we have both - open to the kids sometimes, closed sometimes.

Good Day! - posted on 06/01/2010

5,888

24

I only have one child and she's two. She comes in my room all the time UNLESS my husband is sleeping. He works nights so he needs to sleep during the day.

But girl, if I had 6 kids and a 7 room house, my room would be off limits too!

Angela - posted on 06/01/2010

524

43

our room is always open for our children. I think right now it is important that they feel that they can come to us whenever they need too, whether it is because of a nightmare or even for a hug and kiss. when they are older and understand the concept of knocking and waiting for our reply to enter, then maybe i will change the rule around and have them have no access to our room. Like what Theresa has said, i love it when my daughter comes into our room and wakes us up with kisses and cuddles...makes the start of my day a lot happier and special.

Deborah - posted on 06/01/2010

146

39

We always had the same policy with our son. He is 3 years old but we have raised him to respect other people's property and space. He was and is only allowed in our room if we are in there. It is all about respecting the space of others. Do you let your kids run wild in each other's rooms? Probably not; because they get upset that someone has invaded their space. I would just teach your children that the same rule applies to Mommy and Daddy and their space. Everyone is entitled to a little privacy and time to themselves. Don't feel guilty, especially since they already have so much space already that they have free rein over. Hope this helps.

Phyllis - posted on 06/01/2010

580

23

My room doesn't even have a door that works properly. It is also right off the kitchen and the only room we can put our computer in. Crappy set up, so it might as well be the second living room.

Sherri - posted on 06/01/2010

9,593

15

P.S. We only have 1 bathroom too so sadly that is a free for all too. 1 in the shower someone brushing there teeth. I wish I could go the bathroom without someone walking in for something all the time.

Sherri - posted on 06/01/2010

9,593

15

We live in a very small house. 3 bedrooms, a living room and kitchen. So with 5 of us, a dog, and 2 cats. It more often than that becomes a free for all because there is no where else to go sometimes.

Rhianwen - posted on 06/01/2010

38

2

Wow....you have 7 bedrooms...I wish!!

There is nothing wrong having your room as YOURS. I try to do the same. My kids can go in there if I say, but not to rootle around in drawers or just play. Something has to be off limits, surely!

Kathy - posted on 06/01/2010

462

15

Our bedroom is our santuary. The kids can come get us at night if there is a problem. We even let them campout on hot summer nights since we have the airconditioner. Each kid has their own room and they are expected to keep it picked up and once a week, cleaned. My son has to ask for permission to hang in his sister room. My daughter doesn't hang in his room since she is 14 and 7yr old stuff is boring. LOL

Stina - posted on 06/01/2010

1,055

19

My kids are 5, 3 and 13 mo. They are not allowed in my room unless I'm in there. As they get older, I can see it becoming more off limits, but I do like them coming in to cuddle in the morning and I like them to know they can come to me in the middle of the night if they have a bad dream.

Liz - posted on 06/01/2010

269

3

Our off limit times are weird. But we like it.



Our son will be 5 in 3 months. He's only allowed to come in while *we're* in there if he's hurt, sick or woke up before us. Otherwise, we're in there to be left alone!



But we do allow him to lay on our bed and watch a movie if we're using the living room TV. I check on him often, but due to the size of our apt I can tell if he's into something he's not supposed to be. (He likes to mess with Daddies C-PAP machine sometimes.)

Emily - posted on 06/01/2010

2,228

8

My kids are welcome in my bedroom. I currently co-sleep with my 9-month-old and probably will for a couple of years. My 3-year-old is welcome in our bedroom if he wakes up scared in the middle of the night. I want my kids to feel they can come to me any time of the day or night if they need something. Now.. my kids are still very little so they're needier. It's possible when they're older I'll have more rules about my bedroom, but not right now.

Renee - posted on 06/01/2010

18

18

my space is my space and if the door is open or he has permission my son is allowed in but if im not in there or i am in there and the door is closed then it is my space. i get that and the bathroom when i need to use it thats it. there is nothing wrong with it they have more than enough other rooms to be in they dont need to be in your room as well and all parents need their space

Tamara - posted on 06/01/2010

51

38

my baby is still a too little for me to leave in the other room very long if he's awake. But once he gets older its going to be off limits unless i invite him in. I don't want him to realize how little i like cleaning. :)