Extended BF can cause obesity?????

Katherine - posted on 03/16/2011 ( 5 moms have responded )





The New York magazine blog Grub Street brought up an interesting juxtaposition the other day, suggesting that American mothers don’t breastfeed long enough, while mothers in the UK breastfeed too long. That’s because most American mothers don’t breastfeed exclusively for the first four months of life as the American Association of Pediatrics recommends, but British mothers are taught to abide by the rules of the World Health Organization that suggest they should offer their infants breastmilk exclusively for the first six months of life.

Dr. Mary Fewtrell, a pediatrician in London, believes “there is a higher risk of a baby developing iron-deficiency anemia and food allergies like celiac disease if kids don’t get certain solid foods before they’re 6 months old.” So the Brits are hoping to move to a model that encourages mothers to start feeding their infants some solids in addition to breastmilk at around 4 months of age.

Interestingly enough, Fewtrell and her colleagues also believe that “prolonged exclusive breast feeding may reduce the window for introducing new tastes, particularly bitter taste which may be important in the later acceptance of green leafy vegetables.” They feel this could “encourage unhealthy eating in later life and lead to obesity.”

What is even more remarkable is that supplementing breastmilk with juice or solids too early is thought to have the same obesity-causing effect. A new study in Pediatrics shows that 20 percent of babies in low-income families in North Carolina “were fed solid foods or juice by age 1 month; and by 3 months old, 70 percent were getting fed something (often fruit juice or added cereal) in addition to milk or formula.” Rodale.com reports that “Infants fed these foods consume 100 more calories a day than infants given only formula or only breast milk, which can lead to babies who are overweight for their height.”

The golden rule then when it comes to feeding an infant seems to be to breastfeed exclusively for the first four months of life, then begin to offer them vegetable puree to ensure they develop a healthy taste palette.

What, what, what??????
Some studies are just ridiculous!!!!


View replies by

Minnie - posted on 03/20/2011




It wasn't even a study, though! It was a review of previous studies, with the results interpreted differently. Lol.

Brenda - posted on 03/19/2011




Idiots. Studies can be manipulated to say anything. They just manipulate who they keep and who they exclude. Show me the populations and how they were picked, then we'll see if it was a worthy study.

Mary Renee - posted on 03/18/2011




I breastfeed my daughter on demand. She ten months old and in the 55 percentile for her weight. She's totally healthy. She never had a drop of anything other than breastmilk till she was 7 months old (started giving her a sippy cup of water on hot days - we live in Hawaii) and didn't have solids till almost 6 months. I'd say we're healthy and happy and I wouldn't do it any other way.

Minnie - posted on 03/17/2011




Yeah- that's based on a REVIEW of studies published in the British Medical Journal. It was only a review, and was basically just interpreted in a different way by the biased reviewers.

Doesn't affect me, because I have LLL on my side as the world's foremost authority on breastfeeding, and research that shows that babies will have sufficient iron levels until at least nine months, typically a year, if mother wasn't anemic during pregnancy and delayed cord clamping was carried out.

Hah. My second had not a crumb until ten months and certainly never purees. Went straight to table food. She still nurses several times a day, is in the third percentile for weight at 2 1/2 years and has eaten more today than my nearly five year old.

You know what encourages HEALTHY eating? Embracing a healthy diet that is comprised of a variety of foods in as natural a state as possible. And eating that way as a family. Not giving your kids junk or going out to fast food joints constantly.

Join Circle of Moms

Sign up for Circle of Moms and be a part of this community! Membership is just one click away.

Join Circle of Moms