Cash for Organs

Jodi - posted on 02/20/2010 ( 2 moms have responded )




Doctors worried about 'cash-for-organs

Hospitals across Australia could be paid to harvest the organs of dead patients under a $17 million federal program.

An "activity-based funding" scheme has been set up under the Organ and Tissue Authority in which hospitals could receive up to $11,400 for each patient who becomes a donor.

The funding is designed to help hospitals cover the costs linked to transplants, but doctors are worried it could be seen as an incentive for hospitals to pressure patients into giving away their organs, the News Ltd says.

The funding proposal has been discussed recently within two Melbourne hospitals and has been endorsed by health ministers, News Ltd says.

"This payment recognises that patients arriving in the ED (emergency department) who are identified as potential organ donors require medical management to maintain their suitability as donors prior to their transfer to ICU," the program's documentation obtained by News Ltd says.

"This payment applies to potential donors that would not normally be transferred to the ICU as part of their treatment or end-of-life care."

Ethicists are encouraging public debate on the funding proposal.

What are your thoughts? Remember, our major hospitals are government funded, and are currently struggling for funding, so keeping a potential organ donor patient alive when coming into emergency does cost money they actually can often not afford. Our hospitals are held accountable for their expenditure, and are already closing down wards because they cannot afford the staff to keep them open.


View replies by

Amie - posted on 02/21/2010




The only time I could see this being a real problem is if the person in charge of someone's living will decides to say yes, when the patient had already stated they did not ever want to donate. Other than that, I agree with Joy, no one can force a person to donate. No matter what a person says if someone does not want to donate their organs they will not donate.

JL - posted on 02/21/2010




I don't see a huge ethinical problem because I myself have already consented to organ donation if something was to happen to me. It is on my drivers license and I have told my family my wishes. Perhaps having this become part of public debate will have more freinds and families discussing openly with eachother how they feel about organ donation so if something does happen things will already be made clear about what they would want. I think even without the money nurses and doctors already try to convince families to donate the organs of their deceased or dying family members because there is such a need for it. It is costly to do and I see the need to have outside funding. I do think no matter how much a nurse or doctor pushes for it most patients and their families will stick to whatever decision they feel is right, whether that is or is not donating.

Join Circle of Moms

Sign up for Circle of Moms and be a part of this community! Membership is just one click away.

Join Circle of Moms